UBC News

Behind the Valuation: Understanding Private Equity Transaction Risk

Episode Summary

Financial results are only part of a private equity investment decision. This episode examines ownership records, contracts, operational liabilities, cross-border regulation, and the role of due diligence in negotiations. Click here to explore Pace Law Firm's corporate guidance.

Episode Notes

When a private equity investor considers acquiring a business, financial performance is often one of the first areas examined.

Revenue, profitability, cash flow, and growth potential help establish whether a company is an attractive investment.

But a company's financial statements do not always reveal everything an investor needs to know.

A profitable business may have major contracts that can be terminated following an ownership change. It may rely on technology that it does not own. It may have unresolved employment disputes, significant debt obligations, or corporate records that require clarification before the transaction can close.

Private equity due diligence is intended to identify these issues before an investment is completed.

The review usually begins with understanding how the business operates.

Investors may examine its ownership structure, customers, suppliers, products, employees, assets, and liabilities.

They also need to understand what type of transaction is proposed.

A controlling acquisition raises different questions from a minority investment. A management buyout or recapitalization may involve additional financing and governance arrangements.

The structure influences which rights the investor receives and which obligations remain with the existing owners.

Financial due diligence examines the company's performance in greater detail.

The review may cover historical financial statements, tax records, debt, cash flow, working capital, customer concentration, and recurring revenue.

A company may report strong earnings but depend on one major customer. If that customer represents a large percentage of revenue, the investor may need to consider what would happen if the relationship ended.

Similarly, reported profitability may need adjustment to account for expenses, compensation arrangements, or other items that are not representative of ongoing operations.

Corporate records are equally important.

Investors need to establish who owns the company and whether the appropriate parties have authority to approve the transaction.

Shareholder agreements, ownership registers, financing documents, and corporate resolutions may contain restrictions affecting ownership transfers, voting rights, or new investments.

Incomplete records can create difficulties when the parties are preparing to close.

Contracts can introduce another set of considerations.

A company may have long-standing agreements with customers, landlords, suppliers, lenders, and commercial partners.

Some of those agreements contain change-of-control clauses.

Depending on the wording, a transaction may require third-party consent or trigger contractual rights that affect the continued relationship.

Those requirements should be understood early because they can influence timing and transaction structure.

Employment due diligence can also shape the investment.

Private equity investors frequently depend on existing managers to continue operating the business.

Employment agreements, executive compensation, incentive plans, benefit obligations, independent contractor arrangements, and workplace disputes may therefore require review.

Canadian and U.S. employment rules can differ, including between provinces and states.

These differences may affect workforce planning and the costs associated with an acquisition.

Intellectual property is another area where the documents need to match the business reality.

A company may rely heavily on software, proprietary technology, trademarks, patents, or other intangible assets.

Investors should establish whether the company owns those rights or relies on licences from third parties.

If an outside developer created important software without a clear assignment, the company's ownership position may require further investigation.

Cross-border investments add complexity.

A Canadian business acquiring U.S. operations, or an American investor acquiring a Canadian company, may face different corporate, competition, foreign investment, tax, employment, and privacy requirements.

Not every transaction requires government approval, but some investments may be subject to mandatory notifications, reviews, or other conditions.

These possibilities should be considered when planning the transaction.

What happens when due diligence identifies a problem?

The finding does not necessarily mean the transaction ends.

It may affect the purchase price, the structure of the investment, or the protections included in the final agreement.

The parties might negotiate specific representations and warranties, indemnities, escrow arrangements, or closing conditions to address identified risks.

Business owners also have an important role before the review begins.

Organized financial records, complete corporate documentation, current contracts, and reliable ownership information can make the process easier to manage.

Preparing these materials early may also identify issues that need attention before negotiations progress.

Private equity due diligence provides a more complete view of the business being acquired.

The objective is to understand the company's financial and legal position, the obligations that come with the investment, and the matters that may affect its operations after closing.

For information about private equity due diligence, corporate transactions, and investments involving Canada and the United States, explore Pace Law Firm's Corporate and Commercial guidance. Click the link in the description to learn more. Pace Law Firm City: Toronto Address: 191 The West Mall Website: https://pacelawfirm.com